For UK contractors, IR35 status used to decide a big share of take-home pay. Outside IR35 you could pay yourself a small salary and take the rest as dividends through your own company; inside, everything went through PAYE, usually via an umbrella company. The difference is still real in 2026/27, but two changes have narrowed it.
What changed
- Dividend tax rose by 2 points from 6 April 2026: to 10.75% in the basic-rate band and 35.75% in the higher-rate band. That cuts the outside-IR35 advantage directly.
- Employer NI has been 15% above £5,000 since April 2025. That raises costs on both sides: for your own company's salary outside, and inside, where it comes out of the day rate through the umbrella.
The comparison at £500 a day
Take 220 days at £500, £110,000 of income. Outside IR35: £2,500 of company costs, a £12,570 salary and the rest as dividends. Inside IR35: an umbrella charging £1,200 a year, which also deducts employer NI and the 0.5% apprenticeship levy before paying you.
Contract income
£500 × 220 daysequals£110,000
Outside IR35
Ltd company, £12,570 salary + dividendsequals£68,751
Inside IR35
umbrella gross pay £94,848 − PAYE and NIequals£65,570
Difference
£68,751 − £65,570equals£3,182
Outside comes to about £68,750 and inside about £65,570: a gap of about £3,180, or roughly 5%. An inside rate of about £530 a day would match the outside take-home.
At other day rates
- £400 a day: outside £58,360, inside £54,520. Inside is about 93% of outside; £435 inside would match.
- £500 a day: outside £68,750, inside £65,570, about 95%; £530 inside would match.
- £650 a day: outside £82,190, inside £77,460, about 94%; £700 inside would match.
These assume no pension contributions, rest-of-UK tax bands and all profit paid out in the year. Pension contributions can reduce tax on either route, and they often change the picture more than IR35 status does.
What to do with this
Don't turn down an inside-IR35 role on the assumption that it costs a fifth of your income. Work out the inside rate that matches your outside take-home, and negotiate towards it. For many contractors that is only 5% to 10% above the outside rate, a much easier conversation with a client than 20% or 30%.
Who decides your status
Under the off-payroll rules, the client decides whether a contract is inside or outside IR35 if it is a medium or large organisation, or a public sector body. If the client is a small company, the decision stays with the contractor's own limited company. Whether a client counts as small follows the Companies Act size tests, which were raised from April 2025, so some clients that used to be classed as medium may now be small, moving the decision back to you.
If you disagree with the decision
- Ask for the Status Determination Statement, which must give the reasons for the decision.
- Use the client's disagreement process; the client must respond within 45 days, either keeping the decision with its reasons or changing it.
- Point to the practical facts that matter: control over how the work is done, the right to send a substitute, and mutuality of obligation.
- Consider HMRC's CEST tool as a reference point, while knowing it does not settle every case.
Negotiating an inside-IR35 rate
If a role is inside IR35, the fair comparison is not the day rate, but take-home pay against an equivalent employee package. An inside role deducts income tax and employee National Insurance at source, and depending on the arrangement, employer costs may be taken from the rate too. Ask the client or agency whether the rate is quoted before or after employer's National Insurance and the apprenticeship levy, and push for a higher inside rate to make up the gap shown in the comparison above.
Tip: Ask the agency or client whether the rate is paid to an umbrella or direct under PAYE. If employer NI is paid on top of the rate rather than out of it, inside take-home is higher than shown here.
The IR35 calculator shows the gap for any day rate.
Questions people ask
- Is CEST's result binding?
- HMRC says it will stand by a CEST result if the information entered is accurate, but tribunals decide on the full facts, so keep records of how the work is actually done.
- How much more do I need inside IR35 at £500 a day?
- In our calculator, about £530 a day inside IR35 matches £500 a day outside, because tax and National Insurance are deducted at source.
- Does an umbrella company take employer costs from my rate?
- Often, yes: many deduct employer National Insurance and the apprenticeship levy from the assignment rate. Ask how the rate is quoted before accepting.
- How long does a client have to respond to an IR35 disagreement?
- 45 days. It must either confirm the decision with its reasons or change it.
- How much less do you take home inside IR35 in 2026/27?
- At £400 to £650 a day for 220 days, about 5% to 7% less than outside IR35, with a £12,570 salary outside and an umbrella inside. The gap narrowed after dividend tax rose in April 2026.
- What day rate inside IR35 matches £500 outside?
- About £530 a day in this example, assuming the umbrella deducts employer NI, the apprenticeship levy and a £1,200 yearly margin from the rate.
- Who decides IR35 status?
- Medium and large private-sector clients and all public-sector clients decide and must issue a Status Determination Statement. For small private-sector clients, your own company decides.
- Who decides IR35 status for a small client?
- If the client is small under the Companies Act tests, the contractor's own company decides. For medium and large clients and public bodies, the client decides.