Forming an LLC doesn't lower your taxes by itself: a single-member LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship by default. The saving people talk about comes from electing S corporation status, which splits your profit into a salary, subject to payroll tax, and distributions, which aren't.
Where the saving comes from
As a sole proprietor you pay 15.3% self-employment tax on 92.35% of your profit (Social Security up to the 2026 wage base of $184,500, Medicare on all of it). As an S corp you pay the same 15.3% only on the salary you pay yourself. The profit above your salary escapes Social Security and Medicare tax.
$120,000 of profit: a real saving
Self-employment earnings
$120,000 × 92.35%equals$110,820.00
Sole prop self-employment tax
$110,820.00 × 12.4% + $110,820.00 × 2.9%equals$16,955.46
S corp payroll tax on salary
$60,000 × 15.3%equals$9,180.00
Saving
$16,955.46 − ($9,180.00 + $2,500)equals$5,275.46
After paying for payroll, a separate business tax return and state fees, the election saves about $5,275 a year here.
$40,000 of profit: it costs you
Self-employment earnings
$40,000 × 92.35%equals$36,940.00
Sole prop self-employment tax
$36,940.00 × 12.4% + $36,940.00 × 2.9%equals$5,651.82
S corp payroll tax on salary
$30,000 × 15.3%equals$4,590.00
Saving
$5,651.82 − ($4,590.00 + $2,500)equals-$1,438.18
At this level the running costs outweigh the payroll tax saved, and the election loses about $1,438 a year.
The reasonable salary rule
The IRS requires S corp owners to pay themselves a reasonable salary for the work they do: roughly what you'd pay someone else to do your job. Setting it very low to avoid payroll tax is a known audit focus. The salary you can defend decides most of the saving.
- Add every extra cost: payroll service, Form 1120-S preparation, state fees and unemployment insurance.
- Check your state: some charge S corp taxes or fees that erase the saving.
- Income tax is similar either way, but the QBI deduction interacts with salary.
Tip: Run the comparison with a salary your CPA would sign off on, not the lowest one possible. If the saving only appears at an unrealistic salary, it isn't a real saving.
The costs that eat the saving
The self-employment tax saving is only half of the calculation. An S corporation brings running costs a sole proprietor does not have:
- Payroll: you must run payroll for your own salary, with withholding and quarterly payroll filings. A payroll service typically costs several hundred dollars a year or more.
- A separate tax return: the S corp files Form 1120-S and issues you a K-1, which usually means higher accounting fees.
- State costs: some states charge S corps extra. California, for example, has an $800 minimum franchise tax and a 1.5% tax on S corporation income.
- Unemployment insurance and other payroll taxes on your salary, depending on the state.
Add these up for your state before deciding. A common rule of thumb is that the election starts to pay off once profit is well above what a reasonable salary for your work would be, often somewhere above $50,000 to $80,000 of profit, but your state and your salary decide the real break-even.
How and when to elect
You elect with IRS Form 2553. For the election to apply to a calendar tax year, it generally must be filed within two months and 15 days of the start of that year, which means by 15 March. Late elections can sometimes be accepted with relief for reasonable cause, but it is far simpler to decide before the deadline. Your LLC stays an LLC legally; only its tax treatment changes.
The middle case: $100,000 of profit
Using the LLC vs Sole Proprietor Tax Calculator with $100,000 of profit, a $50,000 salary and $2,500 of extra running costs, the S corp election saves about $3,980 a year. That is a real saving, but a modest one: a higher salary, a state with extra S corp taxes, or more expensive payroll and accounting could erase much of it. At this level, get a quote from an accountant for the extra work before deciding.
Questions to ask your accountant
- What salary would be considered reasonable for my role and hours?
- What will payroll, the 1120-S return and state filings cost me each year?
- Does my state add taxes or fees for S corporations?
- How does the election affect my QBI deduction and retirement contributions?
Questions people ask
- Does forming an LLC lower my taxes?
- Not by itself. A single-member LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship by default. The saving comes from electing S corporation status.
- At what profit is an S corp election worth it?
- It depends on your reasonable salary and running costs. In the examples here it saves about $5,275 at $120,000 of profit but costs about $1,438 at $40,000.
- What is a reasonable salary for an S corp owner?
- Roughly what you would pay someone else to do your job. The IRS expects it, and setting it very low to avoid payroll tax is a known audit focus.
- When is the deadline to elect S corp status for 2027?
- Generally within two months and 15 days of the start of the tax year, so 15 March 2027 for a calendar year, using IRS Form 2553.
- What does running an S corp cost?
- Payroll for your salary, a separate Form 1120-S return, and state charges, such as California's $800 minimum franchise tax plus 1.5% of S corp income.
- Is an S corp worth it at $100,000 of profit?
- Often modestly. In our example with a $50,000 salary and $2,500 of extra costs, it saves about $3,980 a year, before state-specific costs.