Skip to content
Built in Lahore, PakistanHow we check the math
mathbehind

Stripe vs PayPal vs Paddle vs Lemon Squeezy: Which Costs Less?

The cheapest headline rate isn't always the cheapest choice. Stripe's international surcharges, what a merchant of record does, and a worked fee comparison.

By Muhammad Ahmad, Software EngineerLinkedIn· figures checked

Published , updated . 4 min read.

Want to run your own numbers?Payment Processor Fee Comparison: Stripe, PayPal, PaddleOpen the calculator

Choosing a payment provider looks like comparing two numbers: a percentage and a fixed fee. In practice, three other things decide what you pay: how cheap your product is, how many buyers are abroad, and whether the provider handles sales tax and VAT for you. This guide covers each, with a worked comparison at the end.

The published US rates

  • Stripe: 2.9% + $0.30, plus 1.5% for international cards and 1% if Stripe converts currency. Stripe Tax adds 0.5% to calculate tax, but you still register and file.
  • PayPal Checkout: 3.49% + $0.49, plus 1.5% for international payments.
  • Paddle: 5% + $0.50, as merchant of record.
  • Lemon Squeezy: 5% + $0.50, as merchant of record, plus 1.5% on international transactions.
  • Gumroad: 10% + $0.50 plus card processing of 2.9% + $0.30.

Stripe's international surcharges

Stripe's two cross-border surcharges apply independently: +1.5% when the customer's card was issued outside your account's country, and +1% when the payment currency differs from the currency you settle in. A US seller charging a European card in euros pays 2.9% + 1.5% + 1% = 5.4% + $0.30.

200 sales of $49, all to international cards, charged in USD
  1. Stripe rate

    2.9% + 100% × 1.5%equals4.4%

  2. Stripe per month

    ($49.00 × 4.4% + $0.30) × 200equals$491.20

  3. Paddle per month

    ($49.00 × 5% + $0.50) × 200equals$590.00

  4. Lowest

    Stripeequals$491.20

The same volume with only US customers costs $344.20 a month on Stripe. International cards add $147 a month, and charging in the customer's currency would add another 1%. Stripe's base rate also depends on where your account is: published domestic rates are 1.5% + £0.20 in the UK and 1.5% + €0.25 in the EU for cards from the same region.

What a merchant of record buys you

Someone has to be the legal seller. With a processor such as Stripe or PayPal, that's you. With a merchant of record (MoR) such as Paddle or Lemon Squeezy, the MoR resells your product to the customer and pays you the proceeds. In return for the higher rate, it takes on:

  • Charging the correct VAT, GST or sales tax for each customer's location.
  • Registering for, filing and paying those taxes in each country or state.
  • Handling tax audits and many compliance questions about the sale.
  • Often, fraud screening, refunds and chargeback handling.

A worked comparison

Take a $49 product selling 200 times a month, with 40% of buyers outside the US, and Stripe Tax switched on.

Monthly fees at 200 sales of $49
  1. Stripe rate

    2.9% + 40% × 1.5% + 0.5% taxequals4%

  2. Stripe per month

    ($49.00 × 4% + $0.30) × 200equals$452.00

  3. Paddle per month

    ($49.00 × 5% + $0.50) × 200equals$590.00

  4. Lowest

    Stripeequals$452.00

Stripe is cheapest on fees, and Paddle, the cheapest merchant of record here, costs $138 more a month. Whether that is worth it depends on how many countries you sell into and what an accountant would charge for the tax filings you avoid.

  • A merchant of record usually suits small teams selling digital products into many countries, where VAT registrations multiply quickly.
  • A processor plus a tax tool usually suits larger companies, or those selling mainly in one country, because the lower rate adds up at volume.

Cheap products change the ranking

Fixed fees hurt small prices. A $0.50 fixed fee is 5% of a $10 sale but only 0.5% of a $100 sale. If you sell low-priced items, run the comparison at your real price before choosing.

Tip: Charge in your settlement currency where customers accept it, to avoid Stripe's 1% conversion fee, and check each provider's pricing page for your own country.

How price changes the ranking

Using the Payment Processor Fee Comparison with 200 sales a month and 40% international customers:

  • At $19: Stripe costs about $212 a month (5.6% of revenue), PayPal $253.42, Paddle $290 (7.6%) and Lemon Squeezy $312.80.
  • At $199: Stripe costs about $1,652 (4.2% of revenue), PayPal $1,725.82, Paddle $2,090 (5.3%) and Lemon Squeezy $2,328.80.

Fixed per-transaction fees hurt cheap products most, and the gap between a processor and a merchant of record narrows as prices rise. At higher prices, paying a merchant of record to handle global sales tax often becomes the better deal.

What to count beyond the rate card

  • The cost of registering for and filing sales tax or VAT yourself, including accountant time, if you don't use a merchant of record.
  • Chargeback and dispute fees, and how often your product attracts them.
  • Currency conversion when you are paid out in a different currency.
  • Payout speed, which matters for cash flow.

Questions people ask

Is a merchant of record worth the higher fee?
Often, if you sell to many countries. It handles sales tax and VAT registration, collection and filing for you, which can cost more in time and accountant fees than the fee difference, especially at higher prices.
Why do cheap products pay a higher share in fees?
Most processors charge a fixed amount per transaction on top of a percentage. On a $19 sale the fixed part is a much bigger share than on a $199 sale.
How much does Stripe charge for international cards?
For US accounts, 2.9% + $0.30 plus 1.5% for cards issued abroad, plus another 1% if the currency has to be converted.
What is a merchant of record?
The legal seller of a product. Paddle and Lemon Squeezy act as merchant of record, so they charge, file and pay sales tax and VAT for you.
Is Paddle more expensive than Stripe?
Per sale, yes: 5% + $0.50 against 2.9% + $0.30. But Paddle's rate includes tax compliance that you would otherwise handle, or pay someone to handle, yourself.

Sources

  1. Stripe pricing
  2. PayPal merchant fees
  3. Paddle pricing
  4. Lemon Squeezy pricing
  5. Gumroad pricing