A contractor charging $70 an hour looks expensive next to an $80,000 salary, which works out to about $38 an hour. But that comparison leaves out most of what an employee costs, and it compares paid hours with worked hours. This guide builds the full cost of an employee, turns it into a break-even contractor rate, and ends with the non-cost questions that often decide the matter.
What an employee really costs
Salary is the number everyone starts with and the number that most understates the cost. The full cost is usually expressed as a multiplier of salary, built from:
- Employer payroll taxes: social security, national insurance or similar contributions, which vary widely by country.
- Benefits: health cover, pension contributions and other perks.
- Equipment and software: laptop, licences and tools.
- Workspace, training and recruiting, spread over the years the person stays.
Many businesses land somewhere between 1.2 and 1.5 times salary, depending on country and benefits.
Comparing on the same hours
An employee is paid for about 2,080 hours a year but works roughly 1,700 to 1,850 after holidays and leave. The fair comparison is cost per productive hour: divide the employee's full yearly cost by the hours of work you actually need. That figure is the break-even contractor rate.
Employee
$80,000 × (1 + 10% + 20%) + $6,000equals$110,000
Contractor
$70.00 × 1,800 hequals$126,000
Break-even rate
$110,000 ÷ 1,800 hequals$61.11
Difference
|$126,000 − $110,000|equals$16,000
With 10% payroll tax, 20% benefits and $6,000 of other costs, the employee costs $110,000 a year, 1.38 times salary. Over 1,800 productive hours that is $61.11 an hour, the break-even contractor rate. At $70 an hour, the contractor costs $16,000 more for a full year of work.
Employee
$80,000 × (1 + 10% + 20%) + $6,000equals$110,000
Contractor
$55.00 × 1,800 hequals$99,000
Break-even rate
$110,000 ÷ 1,800 hequals$61.11
Difference
|$99,000 − $110,000|equals$11,000
Below the break-even rate, a contractor is cheaper even for a full year. Above it, the employee wins on cost for full-time work.
When the contractor still wins
The picture flips when you need fewer hours. For a six-month project or a part-time role, you pay the contractor only for the hours used, while hiring brings recruiting costs, notice periods and a commitment you may not need.
A checklist beyond cost
- How long is the work? Short projects and uncertain workloads favor contractors; steady, long-term work usually favors an employee.
- How much direction will you give? If you set hours, methods and daily tasks, the relationship looks like employment, and many countries classify workers by how they are managed, not by what the contract says.
- Is the skill specialized or short-lived? Rare skills needed for a few months are often cheaper to rent than to hire.
- What knowledge must stay in the business? Work that builds long-term knowledge of your product or customers is harder to hand between contractors.
Tip: If you keep a contractor full-time for years, check the classification rules where they work. Misclassification can bring back taxes and penalties.
What employer costs look like in two countries
- United Kingdom: employers pay National Insurance at 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year. On a £60,000 salary that is £8,250, about 13.75% of salary, before pension contributions, which are compulsory under auto-enrolment.
- United States: employers pay 7.65% in Social Security and Medicare taxes on wages, plus federal and state unemployment taxes, and often health insurance, which can add much more.
Plugging a UK-style case into the Contractor vs Employee Cost Calculator: a £60,000 salary with 13.8% employer taxes, 10% for pension and benefits and £4,000 of overheads costs about £78,280 a year for 1,600 working hours. A contractor at £45 an hour for the same hours costs £72,000, cheaper by £6,280. The break-even contractor rate is about £48.93 an hour.
Part-time needs change everything
The comparison swings sharply when you do not need someone full-time. In the calculator's default case, if the work only needs 1,000 hours a year, the contractor costs $70,000 against $110,000 for the employee, and the contractor rate could rise to about $110 an hour before the employee became cheaper. Many small businesses hire full-time staff for work that would fill half the year.
The costs that don't show on a payslip
- Recruitment: advertising, agency fees and management time, often a significant share of a year's salary.
- Onboarding: the first months at reduced productivity.
- Equipment, software seats and office space.
- Management time, training and reviews.
- Legal risk: treating a contractor like an employee can lead to misclassification claims and back taxes.
Questions people ask
- How do I avoid misclassifying a contractor?
- Treat them as an independent business: agree deliverables rather than hours, let them choose how and when to work and use their own tools, and avoid managing them like staff. Rules differ by country, so check local guidance.
- When is a contractor cheaper than an employee?
- Usually when the work is part-time, short-term or highly specialised. In our example, at 1,000 hours a year a contractor at $70 an hour costs $70,000 against $110,000 for the employee. For steady full-time work over several years, an employee is often cheaper.
- How much does an employee cost on top of salary?
- Typically 20% to 50% more once payroll taxes, benefits, equipment, workspace and recruiting are included. The example here comes to 1.38 times salary.
- How do I compare a salary with a contractor's hourly rate?
- Divide the employee's full yearly cost by the hours of work you need, usually 1,700 to 1,850 for full-time. Compare that break-even rate with the contractor's quote.
- How much does a UK employee cost above salary?
- Employer National Insurance is 15% above £5,000, so £8,250 on a £60,000 salary, plus pension contributions, benefits and overheads.