A contractor's hourly rate looks expensive next to an employee's salary, but a salary is only part of what an employee costs. Payroll taxes, benefits, equipment and paid leave add a large share on top. This calculator compares the two on the same hours of actual work.
Figures checked by Muhammad Ahmad against IRS: Independent contractor vs employee and US DOL: Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). Prices and rules change, so confirm with the official source before relying on them. How we check the math
How it works
Employee cost = salary × (1 + employer taxes % + benefits %) + other yearly costs. In many countries the total lands between 1.2 and 1.5 times salary.
Contractor cost = hourly rate × the productive hours you need. You pay contractors only for time worked, while employees are also paid for holidays and leave.
The break-even contractor rate is the employee's total cost divided by productive hours. A contractor charging less than that is cheaper for the same output.
A worked example
An $80,000 salary plus 10% payroll taxes, 20% benefits and $6,000 of other costs totals $110,000 a year. For 1,800 productive hours, the break-even contractor rate is $61.11. A contractor at $70 an hour costs $126,000, so the employee is $16,000 a year cheaper.
More examples
If you only need 600 hours a year, a $70-an-hour contractor costs $42,000 against $110,000 for the employee, $68,000 less. The contractor rate would need to exceed about $183 an hour before the employee became cheaper.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the contractor's rate with salary alone.
- Assuming you need a full-time person for part-time work.
- Ignoring misclassification risk when a contractor works like an employee.
- Forgetting recruitment and onboarding costs.
Questions people ask
When does a contractor make more sense?
When the work is short-term, part-time, highly specialized, or uncertain. You avoid hiring and notice costs and pay only for hours used. For steady, full-time work, an employee is usually cheaper per hour.
Are there legal risks with long-term contractors?
Yes. Many countries have rules that treat a contractor who works like an employee as an employee, with back taxes and penalties. Check the classification rules where you and the contractor are based.
What should I include in other costs?
Laptop and equipment, software licences, office or co-working space, training, and recruiting costs divided by how many years you expect the person to stay.
How much does an employee really cost on top of salary?
In the US, a common rule of thumb is 1.25 to 1.4 times salary once payroll taxes, benefits, equipment and paid time off are counted. The multiplier varies by country and benefits package.
What is the break-even contractor rate?
The hourly rate at which a contractor costs the same as an employee for the same productive hours. Below it, the contractor is cheaper; above it, hiring is cheaper, all else being equal.
Guides
- The True Cost of an Employee vs a ContractorAn employee usually costs 1.2 to 1.5 times their salary. Here's how to work out the multiplier, compare it fairly with a contractor's hourly rate, and decide which to hire.
- Salary to Hourly: Why Dividing by 2,080 Can Mislead You2,080 is 40 hours times 52 weeks. It is a useful convention, but your real hourly figure depends on the hours and weeks you actually work.